# After Musk punishes Ukraine, how exposed is India to foreign tech?

- Link: https://spdailynews.com/index.php/2026/10/22/after-musk-punishes-ukraine-how-exposed-is-india-to-foreign-tech/
- Published: 2026-10-22T04:33:03+00:00
- Author: anand

U.S. space tycoon Elon Musk recently throttled the military-grade Starshield network
provided by his company SpaceX to Ukraine in retaliation for Ukraine’s attacks on
Russian oil infrastructure, _The Wall Street Journal_ has reported. Musk’s actions
are not without precedent — with a similar move in 2022 (although SpaceX disputed
media reports) — but his most recent transgression should put other countries still
using or planning to use his services on alert.

That includes India. The Indian government and industry have thus far resisted Starlink’s
entry. Musk is unhappy and likely to keep pushing. On the flip side, quite a bit
of India’s critical infrastructure is exposed to services provided by other foreign
operators. They have acted lawfully so far, but the country still retains strong
incentives to substitute them with homegrown alternatives.

The worst possible outcome on the spectrum of possibilities vis-à-vis India is for
a foreign operator to directly restrict a continuing service. Two other possibilities
include foreign-controlled platforms disrupting access to an otherwise Indian system
and a foreign supplier non-abruptly degrading India’s ability to sustain important
capabilities.

![](https://th-i.thgim.com/public/incoming/vi0z8f/article69930191.ece/alternates/
SQUARE_80/iStock-1344988471.jpg)

#### Satellite communications

The Indian government has currently licensed three companies to provide satellite
communications services: Starlink, the Indian subsidiary of Eutelsat OneWeb, and
Jio Satellite Communications. As of October 16, none had received the security clearance
they need to offer broadband services provided by commercial satellites.

The French company Eutelsat operates the Eutelsat OneWeb satellite network, in which
the French government holds a 29.65% stake, the British government 10.89%, and Bharti
Space 17.88%. Bharti Airtel also separately owns 26% of OneWeb’s Indian subsidiary.

Finally, Jio Platforms and the Luxembourg-based communications satellites provider
SES announced a joint venture in 2022 in which Jio would own 51% in exchange for
being able to use the provider’s satellites. However, again, even majority Indian
ownership of the business doesn’t yield control of the network to Jio.

That said, India doesn’t depend all that much on foreign satellite networks for 
communications at large: most ordinary telephone and internet traffic travels over
terrestrial networks and the two score communications satellites the Indian Space
Research Organisation (ISRO) has launched since 1981 support broadcasting and strategic
communications. The country also has dedicated military satellite communications
capabilities.

Note, however, that the three aforementioned ventures plan to provide satellite 
broadband services alone.

![](https://th-i.thgim.com/public/incoming/m72i3r/article69786489.ece/alternates/
SQUARE_80/Sexual_Misconduct_Epstein_97510.jpg-c4b59.jpg)

#### Satellite navigation

India’s position is particularly weak here because it has fumbled the setting up
of its NavIC constellation, a group of satellites to provide position and navigation
services over the Indian subcontinent the same way the U.S. GPS system does around
the world.

On July 29 this year, Minister of State for the Department of Space Jitendra Singh
admitted in Parliament that only three NavIC satellites are at present able to provide
positioning, navigation, and timing (PNT) signals, i.e., that the constellation 
currently can’t provide standalone positioning services. At least four satellites
are required for this purpose.

The U.S. discontinued its policy to be able to deliberately degrade global civilian
GPS accuracy in 2000 and committed to not reinstating that mechanism. However, it
retains the ability to deny PNT services for military purposes over specific areas.

A less-than-direct but nonetheless important reason India hasn’t been able to maintain
NavIC’s functional integrity is ISRO’s ongoing difficulties with improving its launch
rate.

![](https://th-i.thgim.com/public/incoming/e15i1z/article70885090.ece/alternates/
SQUARE_80/ISRO-collaboratGGQFS19IP.3.jpg.jpg)

#### Cloud computing and IT

Amazon Web Services (AWS), Microsoft Azure, and Google Cloud currently provide cloud-
computing infrastructure and managed services to thousands of businesses and public
institutions in India, with Gartner forecasting that Indians’ expenditure on cloud
services would reach $17.5 billion in 2026.

That said, the government operates its own cloud infrastructure, called MeghRaj,
through the National Informatics Centre (NIC). In December 2025, the government 
reported that 2,170 ministries and departments were hosting applications on MeghRaj,
but that they also depended on empanelled private cloud providers, including those
based abroad.

In February, AWS and an Indian company named Yotta announced they would deploy AWS
Outposts technology for MeghRaj 2.0, allowing cloud services managed by AWS to operate
from within NIC data centres and thus keeping Indian data physically within India.

However, the AWS documentation says Outposts need a connection to an AWS regional
control system for monitoring and software updates, meaning it’s possible the arrangement
will continue to leave Indian physical infrastructure exposed to a management service
controlled by foreign operators.

In the cloud-computing as in the satellite services domain, while the providers’
actions are constrained by contracts and Indian law, the services they deliver technically
depend on their systems.

Finally, experts have also called to increase adoption of open-source software, 
including operating systems. The Union government’s 2015 policy already made open-
source software the preferred option for e-governance projects. The Centre for Development
of Advanced Computing, under the Ministry of Electronics and IT, has developed the
Linux-based ‘Bharat Operating System Solutions’.

A good example from recent memory was a defective update from the U.S. cybersecurity
company CrowdStrike disrupting Windows computers worldwide, including at Indian 
airlines, airports, and securities firms. Not all disruptive actions are retaliatory
but are disruptive nonetheless.

![](https://th-i.thgim.com/public/migration_catalog/article13286116.ece/alternates/
SQUARE_80/20kiep_warrier.ART_GK34BH6L7.120TVEPTIFR.jpg)

#### Digital payments

The National Payments Corporation of India operates the Unified Payments Interface(
UPI) and the domestic infrastructure provides India with considerable independence
from Visa and Mastercard. That said, the consumer-facing layer is non-trivially 
concentrated in businesses controlled by foreign players such as Google Pay, owned
by Google.

However, Google Pay shutting down would not disrupt UPI itself: users could simply
switch to another solution, such as PhonePe. (Although U.S.-based Walmart has a 
majority stake in PhonePe, it can’t control the underlying infrastructure itself—
unlike with the Jio-SES venture.)

That said, banks also operate within payment and correspondent banking networks 
that involve foreign institutions. This is why, for instance, the European Union
decided in 2022 to disconnect select Russian banks from the SWIFT transaction messaging
network, significantly upsetting the ability of affected banks to access international
payment channels.

India could face comparable disruptions if foreign governments imposed sanctions
affecting Indian financial institutions even if the relevant banks have not violated
Indian law. As a result, in the larger scheme, domestic payment systems like UPI
insulate against but don’t eliminate exposure to the risks accompanying cross-border
commerce.

#### Military equipment

After the Operation Shakti nuclear tests in 1998, the U.S. imposed sanctions on 
India, including restricting military supplies. As a result, the Comptroller and
Auditor General later found that the 30 LHTEC T800 helicopter engines Hindustan 
Aeronautics Ltd. had ordered from a U.S.-based manufacturer in April that year couldn’t
be delivered. So HAL nixed the arrangement and ordered replacements from a French
manufacturer.

Both parties here acted within the law (such as they were) and neither engaged in
unilateral corporate retaliation like Musk has. Yet a foreign political decision
still disturbed an Indian procurement programme.

According to a Stockholm International Peace Research Institute (SIPRI) analysis
published in March this year, India was the world’s second-largest importer of major
arms between 2021 and 2025. Russia accounted for 40% of these imports, with India
increasingly also purchasing equipment from France, Israel, and the U.S.

Even the indigenous Tejas fighter programme banks on U.S.-made GE Aerospace engines,
and delays in the delivery of these machines have already constrained production
and pushed delivery deadlines.

_mukunth.v@thehindu.co.in_

[Source link ](https://www.thehindu.com/sci-tech/science/musk-punishes-ukraine-how-exposed-is-india-to-foreign-tech-explained/article71607362.ece)
